I've had bad luck with Penhalgon's. I loved Amaranthine.... but not on me. I ended up giving it away. Ditto Ostara.
The only scent I've ever liked by them was Elixir, which has been discontinued.
Still, I took the plunge and got two recent releases, which were on sale. Bought them both blind. As Sawira and Alizaren.
Nishane Istanbul Wulong Cha Perfume Winner
3 hours ago